Matvey Zakharov
RU

Large or “good” customers may actually destroy margin

Margin is not counted per customer after what serving him costs. So high-revenue customers or jobs look like the best ones while they can consume disproportionate labor, support, discounts, rework, or capacity.

Whose time the largest client takes

Client K1 brings 51% of revenue and 25% of the margin left after serving clients; after repricing and limits, 56% and 59%. In each box: the team's hours a month and his share of them.

Before
The teamHours a month: 1,933
ProductionHours a month: 979K1: 51%
Design and prepressHours a month: 514K1: 68%
Client supportHours a month: 327K1: 70%
SalesHours a month: 113K1: 18%
Share of K1 in revenue: 51%
After
The teamHours a month: 1,510
ProductionHours a month: 926K1: 54%
Design and prepressHours a month: 283K1: 56%
Client supportHours a month: 197K1: 64%
SalesHours a month: 104K1: 19%
Share of K1 in revenue: 56%
The bar: his share of the team's hours; the black line: his share of revenue. Red: his share of the hours is 10 points or more above his share of revenue.

Which revenue is worth keeping

Clients by the margin left after serving them: attractive (10 and more left from 100 roubles of revenue), to reprice (0 to 10), to reduce or exit (below 0). Margin after service: RUB 5.2M a year before, RUB 9.7M after; revenue RUB 47.0M and RUB 46.4M.

Before
After
AttractiveTo repriceTo reduce or exit
A branch is as thick as its revenue. The groups are set from the year before the change; after it, each client is counted again.
SOLUTION

Contribution-margin accounting

  1. From your orders, time records and rework, I count what serving each client costs and what margin he leaves after it.
  2. Clients fall into three groups: worth keeping, to reprice, and to reduce or stop.
  3. For clients to reprice, I draw up prices for revisions, urgent work and support, and limits on what stays free.

What an engagement produces

  • Margin after service for every client
  • Where your team's hours go, by client
  • The split: keep, reprice, reduce or stop
  • Prices and limits for revisions, urgent work and support
  • Setup in your tools, or oversight if you set it up yourself

Rules, thresholds, scripts and automation logic are engagement deliverables and are not published here.

Find out whether this is actually your constraint.

Explore another problem