Matvey Zakharov
RU

The owner cannot tell whether someone is valuable or merely irreplaceable

Performance is confused with accumulated tribal knowledge or control over critical information.

Who is on the podium

Before: the ranking the owner sees, by how often colleagues come to a person for help over 6 months. After: the ranking by jobs finished over the same months. Operator 6 is number 1 in the first and number 5 in the second.

Before
Operator 7came for help: 199
2
Operator 6came for help: 700
1
Operator 9came for help: 146
3
  • 4. Operator 8: came for help: 106
  • 5. Operator 11: came for help: 106
  • 6. Operator 10: came for help: 65
After
Operator 7jobs: 614
2
Operator 8jobs: 660
1
Operator 9jobs: 604
3
  • 4. Operator 11: jobs: 551
  • 5. Operator 6: jobs: 509
  • 6. Operator 10: jobs: 474

The senior operator's report card

Operator 6's jobs a month and the processes only he knows, before and after his knowledge was written down and passed on. His jobs stay the same: 85 a month, against 96 for the median operator.

Report card: operator 6
BeforeAfter
Jobs a month8585
The median operator9696
Processes only he knows70
SOLUTION

Role-output measurement & knowledge separation

  1. From your CRM, task records and messengers, I count each person's output in their role and, separately, how often others depend on them for knowledge or information.
  2. Knowledge that only one person holds is written down and passed on, so that dependence on that person falls to what the role requires.
  3. Output per role is counted every month. Decisions to retain, replace or develop someone rest on output; how hard someone is to do without no longer weighs on them.

What an engagement produces

  • Output per person in each role
  • A separate count of how often others depend on each person
  • Knowledge held by one person, written down and passed on
  • A monthly report on output per role
  • Setup in your tools, or oversight if you set it up yourself

Rules, thresholds, scripts and automation logic are engagement deliverables and are not published here.

Find out whether this is actually your constraint.

Explore another problem